Out of 39 people in attendance, here’s how Mister O’s fared:
And Mr. President beat out Mr. Worldwide in the “Who would win in a fight?” category.
Ryan M. Carroll: The fries were pretty tasty but very undercooked. The burger was pretty tasty but greasy/decadent/heart attack-inducing. I wouldn’t eat it again.
Chris Hires: Needs more acid, but I always say that. Appreciate the toppings tho!
Sarah Scarlata: If I went to Ralph’s and bought ground beef, slapped it on a grill, and called it a day, it would have been a world above this $18 burger. No wonder I got the bill before the burger, I think it was a preemptive strike. They must know the burger ain’t worth 18 bones!
Michael Sherwood: A lot of great ideas, but just fell a little short on the execution.
Brayden: Really appreciated the spicy kick from the peppers, and the patty was delicious! Also appreciated the amount of cheese on my burger – STACKED.
Dan Macken: Going to the bathroom here is truly something special. The cool touch of the weighted bead curtain, and the delightfully rain stick-esque sound really brought me joy. That is NOT an $18 burger.
Stone Irr: Inconsistent fries, had great service, very cheesy burger, fun to eat but so much went to where it was slightly gristle-y.
Noah Shimbaum: Decent burger, not worth the price.
Jamin M.: I ordered my burger medium rare. My burger came out cold, but that’s not rare.
Rinat: I was also given this ballot – thank you for having me! – Maggie from Hopeless Records
Koichi: I ate on a footstool.
Jon Hafter: I had a lamb burger at lunch just so I had a burger base to start from. The lamb burger was boring, so the bar wasn’t high. My Mister O burger came on a burned mushy bun that just tasted sad and burned. Luckily the toppings were tasty and raised the otherwise meh meat to a higher level. Good onions, peppers, and cheese whiz. Not so good cooked thru burger and burned bun. Good ambiance (see fries).
Rye: Quite an…experience!
Robin Hansel: French fries undercooked, server forgot to place burger.
Jon Rosner: Nice looking place!
Martina Comuzzi: God bless this place and their offering of the Impossible burger!! Legends!
Ieva B.: I had my burger in lettuce. Is it a salad or a burger?
Keith Armstrong: Incredible service for how busy it was. I love a good simple burger and this was that!
Sean Johnson: Rather confident the rat pack would approve of this modest contemporary spin on an old school burger.